Mark Schroeder’s Movie Reviews

Hacksaw Ridge

Written in

by

Grade: A-

As a moviegoer, isn’t it wonderful when a film pleasantly takes you by surprise? While making my way through this year’s Best Picture nominees before the Oscar ceremony, I was not anticipating Hacksaw Ridge with excitement. I was anxious to get this 2 hour and 19 minute war movie over with so I could cross it off the list and move on. I found it, however, to be a minor miracle; a beautiful, shimmering, inspiring piece that kept my attention and got so many things right. I don’t know what motivated director Mel Gibson to tell this amazing story, but I’m so glad he did. Hacksaw Ridge tells the true story of Desmond Doss, a humble young passionate Christian from Virginia who enlists in the Army, but refuses to fire a single shot or even bear a weapon – instead, wants to train to be a medic. He wants to save people, not kill people. He is described as a “conscientious objector,” and is not too popular with the men he’s serving with, and especially his drill Sergeant (a marvelous Vince Vaughn – who knew he had this kind of role in him?). I smiled with delight as Vaughn’s character made his first entrance, storming into the bunk with the men lined up at attention, and coming up with nicknames for each of them – most of them derogatory. My favorite was his quip to the tall lanky guy who slightly resembled a corpse. “How long have you been dead?”

After an infectiously watchable first act laden with beautiful scenery, small-town old-time charm, puppy love at the picture show, and complications with the law which ultimately result in Doss being allowed to stay in the military, the second half takes place at Hacksaw Ridge, where it delves into war movie territory. Doss is up there in the front lines, helping and saving as many lives as possible. He ends up being the first American man to receive the Medal of Honor, who never took a life. Best Actor Academy Award nominee Andrew Garfield brings the perfect straight-edged tones of honor and sincerity to the leading role of Desmond Doss. Truly an astonishing man and story. I normally rail against films that end with captions that tell us what ends up happening to everybody, but here, it puts the ideal button on things, and we even see interview footage of some of the “real life” people. Hacksaw Ridge is a revelation. It filled me with a surprising amount of pride.

Grade: A-

6 responses to “Hacksaw Ridge”

  1. […] as good a war movie as I’ve ever seen, and is up there with my favorites from the genre, like Hacksaw Ridge and Enemy at the Gates. This time 20 years ago, director Sam Mendes was about to garner an Oscar […]

    Like

  2. […] is one of my least-liked genres – my favorites of which continue to be Enemy at the Gates, Hacksaw Ridge, and 1917. But All Quiet on the Western Front has its moments, in the midst of my admiring the […]

    Like

  3. […] This has been the season for actors appearing in two recent high-profile movies. Michelle Williams is in All the Money in the World and The Greatest Showman. Lucas Hedges appears in both Lady Bird and Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri. Ditto for Tracy Letts, who is in Lady Bird and The Post – and I’ll go ahead and throw in Bradley Whitford for Get Out and The Post. And now we have Timothee Chalamet, who was awesome in Lady Bird, and is even better in Call Me By Your Name. He plays Elio Perlman, a 17-year-old living in Northern Italy circa 1983. Part of his character reminds me of myself in that it seems like the most comfortable and best he is at expressing himself and “sharing his heart” is when he plays a musical instrument. Elio loves to play classical pieces on piano and sometimes even fingerpicks them on guitar. The film begins with the arrival of Oliver, played by Armie Hammer. Go ahead and mentally make a baking soda joke. I certainly did the first time I saw the name of this gifted actor from Hacksaw Ridge. […]

    Like

  4. […] Sometimes I get surprised by how much I end up loving a particular movie, like what happened with Hacksaw Ridge. And then there’s times, like now, where my reaction is exactly what I’d […]

    Like

  5. […] Double Oscar nominee Andrew Garfield was my pick for Best Actor for tick, tick… BOOM! – and Hacksaw Ridge, his other nod, was as great a war movie as I’ve ever seen. I’m glad these actors live in our […]

    Like

  6. […] Warfare doesn’t join the trio I always name as my three favorite war films (Enemy at the Gates, Hacksaw Ridge, 1917), but it’s compact at 95 minutes, is well-filmed, and the actors are committed, to say the […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Call Me by Your Name – Film Reviews by Mark Cancel reply