Grade: C

One of the few times that a rewatch changed my mind about a grade was with Con Air. I saw it in the theater in 1997, and my intense, high-strung 16-year-old self’s reaction was “This is ridiculous. How can anyone take this seriously? C+.” I gave it another shot in the mid-2000s. My hopefully more mature mid-20s self’s reaction was “This is ridiculous? How can anyone take this seriously? I certainly didn’t, but it doesn’t look like we’re meant to. What a fun summer movie this is. I can picture people seeing it then going down the road to Chili’s or Applebee’s for a burger and a beer while they say to their buddies ‘Wasn’t Con Air a trip?’ B.”
Best Pancakes in the County is a similar situation. This time around, I can already recognize what it’s doing, but the silliness isn’t enough to make it too enjoyable. It even has the same “star.” I put that word in quotes because I want to warn you that there’s a bait-and-switch happening here. Nicolas Cage is front and center in the poster, and his name is at the top, above the title. He’s in the pre-credits opening scene, then the credits display 7 or 8 actors’ names, finally ending with “and Nicolas Cage.” He’s only in about a third of the film, not showing back up until the final act.
The dialogue is like a daytime TV action crime drama, and it feels like we’ve been dropped in the middle of it, having missed the setup. Agents from various organizations, as well as some hitmen/hitwomen, descend on a remote rural diner in the late morning, after the “breakfast rush.” I’ll quickly acknowledge how lucky it is that not a single customer arrives at the restaurant for the rest of the day, while whatever’s going down is going down. In the meantime, right off the bat, everyone is barking orders about where to stand guard, where the snipers will plant themselves, and to have “eyes” everywhere. They’re waiting for Cage to show up, and so are we. Come to think of it, I understand the plot a little better just now after writing this than I did while watching.
The real stars are Justin Long as the cook and Shelley Hennig as the waitress. Barbarian and It’s a Wonderful Knife had Long playing slimy characters I didn’t like. He’s slimy here too, but brings a likable leading man quality that was nice to see. I can’t believe I’ve never seen Hennig before, but she is great, and I’ll continue to watch out for her.
And then there’s Cage, who seems to say yes to everything these days. It feels like he has a movie coming out every 5 minutes, 400 days a year. In Best Pancakes in the County, his nose resembles a pig’s nose, he looks like Elliott Gould, and often sounds like Ernie from Sesame Street. When he gets shot in the hand, he repeatedly yells “I can’t find my thumb!” Then when he presses a button that does something (I don’t want to spoil everything), he does so with his mangled partial thumb, and screams in pain, followed by blowing on it like it’s on fire. Somebody tells him “it’s ok, you still have another one.”
There’s a better movie buried within Best Pancakes in the County. In fact, it’s already been made. If you want an action dark comedy with a diner as the primary set piece, popping dialogue that will remind you of Tarantino, effective ensemble work, and a soundtrack with well-used needle-drops, 2024’s The Last Stop in Yuma County is worth checking out on Paramount+ or Prime Video. I won’t be revisiting Best Pancakes in the County in the mid-2030s, much less elevating my grade. If I do, I’ll give all of you $100.
Grade: C
Leave a Reply