Grade: B+

I wondered how close to reality the events depicted in I Play Rocky were. The IMDb trivia page for Rocky (1976) shows that it wasn’t as embellished as I thought. So much of what I read there appears in I Play Rocky exactly the same way. To go even further, watching the trailer for the original Rocky made me fully appreciate how certain shots were uncannily recreated for I Play Rocky. They really did their homework.
I had no idea what an ordeal it was to make Rocky. It started with a screenplay taken to a studio by up-and-coming aspiring actor/writer Mike Stallone. I’ll get to the “negotiation” process in a minute, but once filming commences, the budget is 25% of what they originally asked for. They didn’t secure permits to film anywhere, and therefore just showed up wherever they could get a shot and hoped for the best. The studio is almost hoping they fail, looking for any excuse to shut it down. They threaten to pull the plug if production gets even a little bit behind schedule. Stallone has to press on through injuries and sickness. The crew lies to the doctor. “Yes, Doc, he’s totally gonna do what you say, and stay off that foot for a couple weeks. No problem.”
The title comes from Stallone’s adamancy about playing Rocky in the movie. The studio wants to get a star, like Clint Eastwood. “Nope,” he keeps telling them. “I play Rocky” — or he walks. They throw money at him to reconsider. $25,000. $50,000. Up to over $300,000. This isn’t chump change in 1975. He turns down every offer, until they finally agree to let him star. Separately, the producers have to accept a budget of $1 million, down from the $4 million they initially tried to get.
My favorite performance in a cast that has several nominatable ones came from AnnaSophia Robb as Sasha, Mike’s girlfriend-turned-wife. She is the one (at least here) who encourages Mike to use Sylvester, his birth name, as his professional name. That went well. In an inspired callback, director Peter Farrelly brings back a star from his There’s Something About Mary. Matt Dillon is effective and convincing as Stallone’s dad. Tracy Letts is great as the studio executive, and Jay Duplass is a scene stealer as John Avildsen, the director they bring in because they know he can get it done quickly.
I was surprised by how easily Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester grew on me. He looks like him and sounds like him, but I was afraid that I wouldn’t be able to overcome the voice, which at first comes across like a Saturday Night Live impression. It didn’t take me long to stop thinking about it entirely, and accept it. By the end of I Play Rocky, all of the stuffy skeptical studio heads are won over. You could also say that about this viewer.
Given how the production happened, with all the obstacles, if I had been alive then and heard about it, I’d have thought Rocky would end up being a “select theaters” indie movie. It did much better, with a heaping handful of sequels and an Oscar Best Picture win. Rocky, I hear, is an uplifting underdog story, and so is I Play Rocky. I left with a pep in my step. One day, I’ll watch the “spinoff” from 50 years ago. I’ve never seen it.
Grade: B+
Leave a Reply